The work your star performer makes everyone else do

Five steps to take before you promote them

Yesterday I sat with a senior leader deciding whether to promote one of his strongest people. The candidate under discussion is sharp. He is known for reading the business better than most of the people sitting above him. He is also known, by his peers and by everyone who has ever reported to him, for how badly he treats them. Nobody in the room disputed either fact.

What I heard next were three excuses I have heard in a lot of rooms. “His heart is in the right place.” “He is only trying to make the work better.” “He will change his mind if you come at him the right way.”

When you explain a top performer’s behavior by his intentions rather than his actions, you are not describing him. You are assigning unpaid work to everyone who has to work with him. Everyone else adjusts so that he does not have to.

When you explain a top performer’s behavior by his intentions rather than his actions, you are not describing him. You are assigning unpaid work to everyone who has to work with him.

Take the third excuse literally, because the people around him already do. He will change his mind if you come at him the right way means that there is a right way. Finding it takes preparation, and the preparation happens on somebody else’s evening.

His director already writes two versions of every recommendation and decides which one to lead with. His counterpart in finance walks a number past a third person first, so the challenge lands in front of a witness. None of that time shows up in a job description or in anybody’s compensation.

You pay for those hours, just not as a line item. The bill arrives when two capable directors leave with exit reasons that never quite add up, and when the bench thins in the middle while the top of the house still looks fine.

Christine Porath and Christine Pearson put numbers on the hours. In their survey of 800 managers and employees across 17 industries, 63 percent said they lost work time avoiding the person who had treated them badly. Eighty percent lost work time worrying about how they were being treated. Just under half deliberately reduced their effort.

Treat those numbers as a labor cost. Avoidance takes hours, and so do the pre-briefing and the rewriting that go with it.

An even harder finding comes from Michael Housman and Dylan Minor, who studied 58,542 workers across 11 firms for a Harvard Business School working paper. The data came through Cornerstone OnDemand, the talent software company where Housman worked at the time. In those jobs, output was measured by how long a worker took to finish one unit of work.

The people later fired for serious misconduct finished faster than everyone else. Their work was also lower quality, so the advantage completely disappears once you adjust for that. The authors argue that speed is the reason such workers get hired and kept.

That describes the candidate my client was evaluating. The number on his scorecard, the same number that put him on the slate, is real, and it is the only measure that flatters him.

Housman and Minor also priced the pattern. Keeping one toxic worker off the payroll saved a firm about $12,489, mostly in the turnover he would have caused around him. Hiring a top one percent performer was worth about $5,303. Avoiding the damage caused by a toxic worker was worth more than twice as much as hiring a top performer.

Those figures come from frontline hourly workers, so do not attach a dollar amount to a senior executive. Scale the logic instead of the number. One frontline worker affects the twenty people on his shift. A senior executive can affect everyone in the organization who has to guess what he wants.

I have watched this go wrong from inside the room. I once sat on a leadership team that promoted someone with average results but above average self-marketing. She ran a charm offensive, using people and their relationships to bolster her reputation. It worked because she had favorable exposure to the board.

We were not fooled. We were afraid. Anyone who moved against her would pay for it later, once she had the board’s ear, and every person at that table had run the same math. So nobody told the board what her performance record actually showed. That was cowardice, and I was part of it. It got her the senior job.

Revenue fell under her and people were laid off. The organization’s standing in its field dropped and has not come back. Everyone below that decision read what the promotion taught them, and they were right. They learned that you can treat people however you want if the right people are in your corner, whether or not you are good at the job.

Before you close the slate on a leader like this, do five things.

1. Address the behavior when you see it, in the room where the excuse gets made. A sentence about what he meant closes the question before anyone can answer it. Once “his heart is in the right place” gets spoken, what he did has been reclassified as a communication style. Write down what he did, to whom, and on what date. Then make the room respond to that instead.

Do not wait for it to be reported. The people around him worked out long ago what reporting him would cost them, and absorbing it costs less. If your only intake is what reaches you, you will conclude the problem is smaller than it is. Go ask.

2. Require amends, and say what makes them real. Ask him to go back to the people he treated badly, name what he did, apologize, and ask for nothing in return. If he refuses, you have learned he cannot rise any higher. No version of that conversation puts the person he harmed in charge of making it comfortable for him. That would be one more piece of work handed to someone already carrying extra for him.

Then watch for 90 days whether anything changes. An apology with no behavior change behind it teaches the organization that a good apology is all it takes. When the change is real and the people he harmed can see it, the organization learns the opposite: nobody here is above correction, and repair is available.

3. Set the consequence against the pattern and its reach. Any single incident, a sharp email or one meeting where he took someone apart, looks small on its own. Priced against that incident, the proportionate response is a conversation, which is what he has been getting for a decade. Price it against ten years of the pattern, and against how many people sit downstream of him.

Then let the consequence be visible to the same people who saw the behavior. As far as the organization is concerned, a closed-door conversation did not happen.

4. Take the read from beside him and below him. He is perfectly visible to his peers and to his team. He is invisible only from the chair that decides the promotion, and that is no accident, because managing upward well and managing downward badly run on the same instinct. Your own experience of him is the least reliable evidence in the file, and it carries the most weight in the room.

Your own experience of him is the least reliable evidence in the file, and it carries the most weight in the room.

Before the slate is set, get instances with dates from two current peers and two people who used to report to him and no longer do. When what you hear from below contradicts what you have seen yourself, believe what you hear from below. He was not performing for them.

5. Promote only on change you have already watched happen. “He will grow into it.” “The bigger job will settle him.” “He is coachable.” Each of those is a bet that his behavior changes after you have paid for it.

Name the behavior, the observable difference, the date you will check, and the person who will tell you the truth. Say all four to him out loud before the slate closes. If the date arrives and nothing has changed, the promotion does not happen. This will not be a surprise, because he knew that going in.

Then hold the slate. The person who gets the job instead is not a consolation prize. Treating them as one is the next thing your organization will read. Say out loud what made them the choice.

The decision about him will be made the way these decisions are always made: behind a closed door, by a few executives weighing his behavior against the company’s stated values and the business’s need for what he produces. I made the longer case in Culture Is Made in the Decisions That Cost You Something that culture gets set in the choices where the standard carries a price. This is one of those choices. Holding the standard will cost you his output for a quarter or two. The excuse has been costing you the people around him for years.

Holding the standard will cost you his output for a quarter or two. The excuse has been costing you the people around him for years.

So prepare for that room. Before the review, pull the notes from the last one and find every sentence that explained someone’s behavior by what they meant instead of what they did. When his name comes up behind that door, ask the others at the table who has been doing the adjusting for him and what it has cost them. Then weigh that answer next to the number on his scorecard.

If it would help to look at who your own process has been protecting, you can find a time here: Schedule a Meeting with Richard Smith

About the author

Recent articles

Stop holding people accountable

Every quarter, in boardrooms and town halls across the Fortune 500, some version of the same sentence gets said with real conviction: we need to